| Across the Water by bitshifters collective [web] | ||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|||||||||||||
|
popularity : 58% |
|||||||||||||
alltime top: #6985 |
|
|||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
added on the 2022-04-17 19:54:53 by P_Malin  |
||||||||||||||
popularity helper
comments
reflections
rulez added on the 2022-04-17 20:00:53 by 100bit 
Love the composition and the lighting!
beautiful!
incredible
Composition. Colors. Wow.
Nice!
Beautiful!
nice
this was cooled really liked this one in the compo
Love that wet street.
In my optinion it's best in compo. I love the lighting and reflections in here.
Nice!
kewl :)
very pretty
love the rocks, the buildings in the background didn't feel realistic enough for me though
Nice
Rejected from the photo compo.
amazing :)
Super use of composing, colors,+ deep blur make this one almost photorealistic!
the intricate modelling of the bricks and cobbles is among the key selling points here, but i feel a lot of the other geometry is a bit... "chibified"? like, the railing just feels a bit too thick, the proportions in the lamp posts just a tad strange, and the corner on the curb just a bit too round. it's small things, but together they result in obvious giveaways that this is CGI scene.
another detail that slightly bugs me is the subject, as it just feels like there is none. for an urban landscape, the expectation would be to have the entire scene in focus as much as possible, but instead the camera is focused a couple meters in front of the lens pointed at... nothing in particular? it still works aesthetically since the bokeh is beautiful, but i still can't shake off the conflicting feeling. similarly the scene also feels a bit too dark? not an easy problem to solve of course... can't just increase the brightness of the light sources when path tracing when your sample budget has a hard limit (kudos for trying the median filter(?) approach though :)).
oh well, feels like i'm merely nitpicking. this is a fabulous entry, and i hope you're not about to run out of steam with these! :)
another detail that slightly bugs me is the subject, as it just feels like there is none. for an urban landscape, the expectation would be to have the entire scene in focus as much as possible, but instead the camera is focused a couple meters in front of the lens pointed at... nothing in particular? it still works aesthetically since the bokeh is beautiful, but i still can't shake off the conflicting feeling. similarly the scene also feels a bit too dark? not an easy problem to solve of course... can't just increase the brightness of the light sources when path tracing when your sample budget has a hard limit (kudos for trying the median filter(?) approach though :)).
oh well, feels like i'm merely nitpicking. this is a fabulous entry, and i hope you're not about to run out of steam with these! :)
@noby
Hah, yes, I agree and I'm very aware of all of those things. There is nothing to hide behind with a "real world" image so all those little things really stand out. I'm happy with what I made though. I like to try things that are a bit different, which I think it is. I still think it has a lot of nice qualities and I played with the ideas I wanted to.
I'm usually guilty of some quirky, niche technical self indulgence rather than making something simpler and more accessible and that is the case here.
The end result is quite different from what I originally had in mind which was to focus more on the cobbles, with more interesting, varied lighting on them, framing a single puddle reflecting something interesting and maybe a drain cover with a design on it. Sticking with that would have been simpler and probably have worked out with a better, more crowd pleasing composition.
However, the process of making it took me in a different direction with the city skyline becoming more prominent. With it becoming harder to wrangle as the complexity grew, ultimately with other more important life commitments I just ran out of time and space to do a lot of those small changes that would have helped the end result.
Hah, yes, I agree and I'm very aware of all of those things. There is nothing to hide behind with a "real world" image so all those little things really stand out. I'm happy with what I made though. I like to try things that are a bit different, which I think it is. I still think it has a lot of nice qualities and I played with the ideas I wanted to.
I'm usually guilty of some quirky, niche technical self indulgence rather than making something simpler and more accessible and that is the case here.
The end result is quite different from what I originally had in mind which was to focus more on the cobbles, with more interesting, varied lighting on them, framing a single puddle reflecting something interesting and maybe a drain cover with a design on it. Sticking with that would have been simpler and probably have worked out with a better, more crowd pleasing composition.
However, the process of making it took me in a different direction with the city skyline becoming more prominent. With it becoming harder to wrangle as the complexity grew, ultimately with other more important life commitments I just ran out of time and space to do a lot of those small changes that would have helped the end result.
So this was one of the entries that suffered a bit at our satellite because the compo was early enough that the light conditions kinda crushed some of the rich darker tones into mush, so I wasn't sure why everyone online was so excited about it - turns out I just didn't see a lot of the detail.
should have ranked first. awesome.
Yup
:)
Amazingly photo realistic! Keep 'em coming! :)
submit changes
if this prod is a fake, some info is false or the download link is broken,
do not post about it in the comments, it will get lost.
instead, click here !