pouët.net

why is there so few Mac demos, compaired to Win?

category: general [glöplog]
For anyone looking to make 4k intros on a Mac, I'd tip them in the direction of Core Audio..
added on the 2008-09-24 15:59:59 by gloom gloom
Majority of Mac's have crappy graphics adapters by default. For example, even Google Earth bugs on my Macmini. This will probably change after OSX 10.6 is being released, or so they say.

Coding on Mac isn't any harder than on PC. You can even skip XCode entirely if you don't like fancy IDE's. Textmate is pretty good for everything in the end.
added on the 2008-09-24 16:08:25 by melw melw
Ok try QuartzCompo tool within XCode dev tools
melw: the majority of pcs have shitty intel onboard rubbish too, in all fairness. It's just a pity there's no 'mid range' mac that's upgradable with a video card.
added on the 2008-09-24 16:19:51 by psonice psonice
The one and only reason is that Windows+PC is what the mainstream uses currently and the scene follows that. It's always been like that, maybe with a lag of a few years. The tools or the hardware don't really have any importance in it.
added on the 2008-09-24 17:24:47 by Marq Marq
that said, it follows that the tools etc are better because the mainstream uses it :)
added on the 2008-09-24 17:40:46 by smash smash
If that's the case, the mainstream is swinging steadily towards osx so the tools should steadily improve. It'll take quite a few years before everyone shifts over though.
added on the 2008-09-24 17:50:24 by psonice psonice
Quote:
If that's the case, the mainstream is swinging steadily towards osx


Oh come on...
Well, windows market share is going down, osx market share is going up. I've a feeling linux share is going up too, but pretty slowly in comparison. It'll take years at the rate it's changing, but that's the way it's headed. Perhaps in that time microsoft can put out an os that makes people happy again, or linux can become a bit more practical for the mainstream. Who knows.
added on the 2008-09-24 18:00:38 by psonice psonice
the 'other' scene is mainly win (linux is used 'only' for distro infrastructure), why would the demoscene migrate to osx ?

personally i like mac groups like Spönz who almost always offers win ports at the same time :)
added on the 2008-09-24 18:11:13 by Zest Zest
I'm not sure on ports. It's great to have ports, I've complaints about them (infact, more osx ports please!) but making stuff multiplatform means you can't take advantage of whatever makes the platform different. Which is a big part of the appeal of doing alternative platform stuff to me :)
added on the 2008-09-24 18:14:56 by psonice psonice
converting to mac requires a pretty big shift in the brain. With XP some coders may have lost patience with microsoft and began converting to mac/linux. But now that vista is here the situation has changed. Maybe they stick around with vista or... btw. iPhone sales may also increase mac sales.
added on the 2008-09-24 18:21:06 by neoneye neoneye
the real problem with linux is, we're in all in the demoscene for the chicks - and there simply arent enough girls using linux to make it worth our while.
perhaps this will help.
added on the 2008-09-24 18:23:03 by smash smash
I'd guess vista pushed more people to other platforms than xp did.
added on the 2008-09-24 18:23:53 by psonice psonice
lol smash this document itself is so sexist and paradoxal, it can't be serious!
added on the 2008-09-24 18:30:10 by Zest Zest
Quote:
the Mac has always been branded as the creative platform


Today's sceners tend not to be brand whores.

I'm on my 2nd mac laptop (replaced the flawed g4 ibook that needed a mobo replacement every 6 months due to that design flaw smug mac owners never talk about). The situation of XCode and OpenGL has not improved, not compared to VS and the incredibly rich library of the DXSDK. Sure all the interesting heavy lifting is done in shaders now but this other stuff matters.
added on the 2008-09-24 18:49:40 by GbND GbND
Demosceners want to reach the largest possible audience. That's my guess.

Other than that I can't find a reason. Windows has been obsolete for years, is not compatible with anything else and is barely usable without installing CygWin.

DX is a piece of crap that should have disappeared in 1998 :)
added on the 2008-09-24 20:21:23 by flynn_nrg flynn_nrg
I think it's ok to reply to the above post using this word:

LOL.

:)
added on the 2008-09-24 20:39:48 by kb_ kb_
Maybe it was some form of sarcasm?
*crosses fingers*
added on the 2008-09-24 20:53:38 by Preacher Preacher
maybe it was some kind of dream bubble?
Quote:
osx market share is going up

Too bad this is mostly related to the sale of laptops (mostly Macbooks with shitty Intel graphics) in North America.
added on the 2008-09-24 22:50:48 by gloom gloom
Quote:
Are positive comments from "unproven" people welcome?


Sure :) But i give it 10 times more value, if the thumb up comes from someone who i respect. Or a thumb down :)

And hey, maybe you all should start making mac demos that run on that crappy piece of intel, it's not THAT bad you know ;) You just need to do some optimizing and clever tricks, instead of throwing an extra million polygons into the screen.

added on the 2008-09-24 23:00:20 by kurli kurli
rainmaker: small correction needed there. You just need to do some optimising and clever tricks, and a large amount of praying that you don't hit one of the many driver bugs that seem to plague the intel chips on osx :(

Having said that, I've come across nasty ones with nvidia too. Seems ATI is actually the best for drivers on mac. And I hear ATI has better core image optimisation, so a mid-range ATI card will outperform a high end nvidia one for quite a few jobs.
added on the 2008-09-25 03:22:28 by psonice psonice
just finished sorting results in SPSS from street poll:
"why is there so few Mac demos, compaired to Win ?"
1-Mac's are fucking expensive here (87%)
2-I can't find warez for it so I won't buy one (10%)
3-No opinion (3%)

in the end it seems less people buys it, could be a reason...
added on the 2008-09-25 05:00:20 by EviL EviL
4-A mac is a mac is a mac...and in the end nothing more and nothing less than a PC.
added on the 2008-09-25 06:47:38 by Raven^NCE Raven^NCE

login