pouët.net

how does your personal top 5 look like?

do you agree on the results how they are ?

read them here:
http://www.pouet.net/results.php?which=450&when=08

My personal top 5 is:

1. Uk AllSTars
2. Cocoon
3. ASD
4. FR+Neuro
5. Traction+Brs

1. FR+Neuro
2. Cocoon
3. UK all stars
4. ASD
5. ...

x. Einklang somewhere on the podium :p

1. FR+Neuro
2. UK Allstars
3. ASD
4. Einklang
5. Cocoon

1. Einklang
2. That thing in Java. ;)
3. Cocoon
4. Excess

And as you can see I completely disagree with official results (well there was a bit of namevoting unfortunately).

Who cares? All the 5 demos mentioned in the original post by Magic are good demos. People vote after their taste, and the results may or may not correspond with your particular taste.

This thread is bullshit.

My personal favorites are the ones from ASD and UKSA... but all of the top five demos deserved to win. They all cater to different tastes so it was quite obvious that this will be a close race. IMHO the real winner was the scene itself, because this was a tremendous demo competition.

What Lug00ber said. This discussion is meaningless.

yeah, excellent compo indeed

lug00ber: according to your (not wrong) reasoning that's the whole pouet bbs which would deserve to be flushed away ;)

Zest: I'm not sure you're really helping your case here ;)

1. Allstars
2. ASD
3. That thing in Java
4. Farbrausch
5. That 3D PC game intro with the gorilla

Anadune
Cocoon
Excess

This thread is indeed pointless, since everyone will always have their personal favourites. I don't think I have ever seen a compo result list which after the party has been completely accepted and agreed upon. :)

After all, Metalvotze won BP a few years back.. now that spawned some pretty funny threads. :)

Yeah, and this thread is where you can express them.

Pointless thread, but entertaining compo. I somehow felt sorry for not having any contribution, but then I drank a lot of sparkling wine and it all felt fine.

Yeah, sparkling wine is quite a nice effect.

If at least your list would feature somewhat interesting comments as to why this or that demo is your favorite.. then we'd be talking. Otherwise it's just a list-thread.

1. ASD

BP08 demo compo sucks.BP07 was much better.Sorry.

I totally disagree. Debris saved 2007 from a below-average compo, in my opinion.

Indeed, what I see here is far better than the bp 2007 entries. Less catering to audience, more introspection, more variety.

I second that. Also: I find that there was some "innovation" in the adopted music stiles, expecially in the PC demo section.